TELL US: Will Longer School Days Help?
Massachusetts is one of five states to add 300 hours of class time every year for certain schools. Will it help?
Will more time in school translate into greater student achievement?
Federal and state officials announced Monday that Massachusetts, along with Connecticut, New York, Tennessee and Colorado, are participating in a pilot program to find out.
Csmonitor.com reports that the program will add at least 300 hours of learning time in some schools starting next fall.
Fall River and Lawrence are the two Massachusetts towns included in the pilot project. Boston.com reports that this new program adds to an effort launched six years ago in Massachusetts to lengthen the school day in several school districts.
The pilot program reportedly will last three years and include almost 20,000 students in 40 schools with an eye to bringing in more schools if it is effective, particularly lower-performing schools in lower-income communities. Each school district gets to decide exactly how the school time will be increased: longer school days? More of them? Both?
The pilot is part of a project called the TIME (Time for Innovation Matters in Education) Collaborative, a partnership between the Ford Foundation and the National Center on Time & Learning (NCTL).
What do you think? Tell us in the comments.
Gina Fishman
1:44 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
Those that know me know that I was a huge fan of the ELT (Extended Learning Time) when Brophy had it for two years. IMO, the extra school time can only help _if_ is it implemented properly and everyone is on board.
Ben Jackson
2:28 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
I think it needs to be staged in for kids. First graders are *exhausted* at the end of most school days. Seventh graders could do with some more exhaustion! Also, the lunch schedules would need to be better managed (no 10:45 lunches if school lasts until 4, for example).
This would be particularly useful if the time was not dedicated solely to math and science, but if it were used to reestablish strong music, art, physical education, and literature focuses. The world needs more than mathematicians and scientists for it to be worth living in.
Also, we would need to be sure to adequately compensate teachers, as well as provide sufficient mechanisims for them to still spend one-on-one time and get their grading in, without ruining the work-life balance. So, lots of logistical challenges, but I think it could be great for kids - which should be the goal of everyone.
Town Resident
4:49 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
It would also be good if the kids had more consistent 5 day school weeks. I find all these 1/2 days and days off disruptive the ths kids schedules. For example spelling words are given on Monday and the test is on Friday. Sometime the teachers still schedule it when there is less than 5 days and sometimes they skip it. If they have a special (art, music, etc.) on one day a week, it can be weeks before they have it again.
Duh!
5:02 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
Ben - You're my new best friend. :-) Thank you!
jhschool
5:17 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
I have to agree with this. We are in our 14th week of school, yet only 4 of them have been full 5 day weeks in the elementary school. Yes, some are holidays, but many are not. I've been shocked how inconsistent the schedule is.
ET
5:44 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
I think adding more time to the school day is not the way to go. Kids are tired and already pressured enough in school, and need down time-- time to be kids. I think taking the learning outside of the classroom with any additional time, an enrichment of sorts, is the way to go. BUt asking kids to sit longer than they already are is not going to be productive at any level and only emphasize negativity against school for some kids.
Maybe too much time is spent teaching for the MCAS and maybe that is something that needs to be addressed. Let teachers have time to delve into other areas that they are currently limited to because of those tests that really don't give a true picture of what a student is capable of and what they really know.
I have to agree with the school schedule often brings inconsistencies to the school year. October and November were bumpy--half days, conference, storm days, teacher professional days, and holiday time. Not to mention kids are missing days for sickness too starting in winter.
I think it is all about better and more efficient ways of using the current time in school.
Joseph Scola
8:16 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
I'm a huge believer in "kids get out of school what they put into it". I'm not in favor of adding additional hours to the school day or extending the year. Those hours and days could be better used doing sports or drama or clubs where they can explore what interests THEM and not have more of the same content shoved on them. The Medfield School System is an excellent system, our kids get a great education already and most of them end up in excellent colleges (if that's their plan). I'm agree with "Town Resident" that all these 1/2 days and other days should be eliminated to provide them with a more consistent, regular, predictable day than the nonsense we endure now.
Anonymous Northborough Resident
9:07 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
What about sports? I know at the highschool sports start at 2:30 and go until close to 8 for some kids. How does adding hours to the day logistically fit in with after school activities? Also the amount of homework given at this point is not anywhere close to a fair amount if we were in school until 4pm. I could see a much less workload if the day was longer as a fair approach. And finally having nothing to do with the length of a school day, the professional development days should be during weekends or the summer. It makes no sense to disrupt a week for the teachers to come to school and do odd activities. The things that apparently develop them are given in classes like yoga etc. when enough credits are achieved. The whole system is corrupt and wont ever be fixed with these unions always getting what they want.
David Nolta
11:57 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
If "these unions" always got what they wanted, do you think teachers would be so badly paid? Yes to more opportunities for physical education, art, drama, creative writing, chess, field trips, etc. A well-rounded education is always the first thing to be threatened in any economically-challenged time, and that winds up being extremely costly in the long run--costly in every sense.
ammazoli
6:21 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Learning happens at home as well, or rather, it should. Our children are not yet in elementary school, but when the time comes, we want our kids to have time to spend with us.
Medfield resident
9:47 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
I agree these half days and full days off are not good for the children and I find they are disruptive to my son. In addition 10 weeks summer vacation is way too long for the children, my child starts getting bored after 6 weeks. Other countries only have 6 weeks vacation time.
Stacey Meninno
11:28 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
More school time is great if there is less (or no) homework. In that case the kids can actually relax and enjoy the rest of the day.
Westborough Graduate
2:26 pm on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
What about considering block scheduling rather than longer school days? Rather than having six classes a day, focus on only three a day, but for two hours each. This allows for more in depth projects and lectures, prepares kids more for the college schedule, and allows them days of reprieve from certain classes they do not enjoy. It also allows for homework to not be constant, but for kids to have a day off from biology homework every other day and allows them to focus fully on their math homework instead. I do not believe making the school day longer is a viable option. Maybe making the school year longer is a better way to go. Sports need those day light hours and students need some time to complete their homework outside of class. If schools do not get out until four, that not only jeopardizes sports but also family time, which is important too.
Concerned Mom
3:29 pm on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
The Advanced Math and Science Academy in Marlboro has a longer day by one hour and it appears to work extremely well. School starts at 8:05 and ends at 3:15 for grades 6-12.